Dates:
- July 8, 2025 — DHS issues a memo adopting the Tacoma theory as national ICE policy: people present without admission are generally ineligible for bond.
- September 30, 2025 — Judge Tiffany Cartwright grants partial summary judgment: interior detainees are under § 1226, not mandatory detention under § 1225(b)(2).
- October 29, 2025 — Government notices its appeal to the Ninth Circuit (No. 25-6842).
- March 4, 2026 — Ninth Circuit panel hears oral argument in Seattle.
- July 30, 2026 — Ninth Circuit affirms 2–1 (Bress, joined by McKeown; Bea dissenting)
Sources:
- https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/washington/wawdce/3:2025cv05240/346178/65/
- https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/judge-rules-strict-bond-policy-in-tacoma-immigration-court-is-unlawful/
- https://dockets.justia.com/docket/circuit-courts/ca9/25-6842
- https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/71839565/87/1/rodriguez-vazquez-v-bostock-et-al/
- https://calmatters.org/justice/2026/07/9th-circuit-mass-detention/
In 2025 the Trump administration adopted a new reading of immigration law that treated almost anyone who had entered the United States without inspection as an “applicant for admission,” even if they had lived in the interior for years. That reading put them under a statute that requires detention without a bond hearing until removal proceedings end. The practice had already taken hold at the Tacoma Immigration Court, which oversees the Northwest ICE Processing Center; a July 2025 DHS memo then made it national policy. A class of detainees sued in federal court in Tacoma. On September 30, 2025, Judge Tiffany Cartwright held that people arrested inside the country fall under the older discretionary-detention statute, which allows immigration judges to set bond. The government appealed. On July 30, 2026, a Ninth Circuit panel sitting after argument in Seattle affirmed 2–1, saying Congress had not clearly ordered mass no-bond detention of long-resident noncitizens and that three decades of contrary practice by both parties confirmed the narrower, border-focused reading. The decision binds courts across the West and restores bond hearings for that class of detainees while the issue heads toward the Supreme Court.
Against the block
The Ninth Circuit’s decision to restore bond hearings for people who entered illegally and were later found living inside the country undercuts a lawful tool Congress already gave the executive to manage removal. Once someone has crossed without inspection they remain, as a legal matter, an applicant for admission; treating them as if they had been lawfully present for years simply because they evaded detection rewards the very conduct the statute is designed to deter. Mandatory detention pending a final order reduces absconding, prevents the release of individuals whose identities and criminal histories are often incomplete, and keeps limited immigration-court dockets from being further clogged by people who have already demonstrated they will not appear when required. Thirty years of looser practice does not rewrite the text; if Congress wanted a different rule it could have said so. Requiring individualized bond hearings for every interior arrest turns a civil enforcement system into a revolving door and signals that illegal presence, once established, is effectively protected rather than merely tolerated until removal can be completed.
